Grammatical Incompatibilities in the New Edition of Tarikh-e Bayhaghi Edited by Yahagghi and Seyyedi

Document Type : Grammar

Author

Associate Professor of Persian Language and Literature, University of Zanjan, Zanjan, Iran,

10.22091/jls.2024.10783.1604

Abstract

Tarikh-e Bayhaghi is one of our most precious historical and literary works and one of the texts that influenced other prose texts after it; Therefore, any work that helps to revise its later corruptions or to describe and explain it, can be an example of preserving this eternal work. Editing such a work, of course, requires the editor’s multifaceted knowledge, including knowledge of the text’s grammar as well as of the period of its creation; Ali Akbar Fayyaz managed to do it well and was so excellent in it that his name became associated with the name of Tarikh-e Bayhaghi. In 2009, Yahagghi and Seyyedi published a new revision of Tarikh-e Bayhaghi in order to correct the problems of Fayyaz's revision but the result of the work unfortunately led to unjustified manipulations in many cases. The publication of the new edition of the book in 1401 also subverted the expectations for the correction of many problems in their book because it seems that the editors do not believe in the existence of these problems. One of the major problems of this correction is the disregard for the grammatical norms in the text and unjustified manipulations in it, which has made it difficult to understand many of its phrases and has damaged the semantic context of the text as a whole. In the present article, we examine some of these manipulations in the grammar of the book, which have led to the grammatical incompatibility of the text, in two sections: "morphology" and "Syntax".

Keywords

Main Subjects

References

  1. ‘AbbasMajid, A. (2019). Barrasi-ye Dastoor-e Tarikhi-ye Zaban-e Dastan-e Khishkhane-ye Tarikh-e Beyhaghi. Motale'at-e Adabiyyat-e Tatbighi. 13(52). Pp. 37-54. [In Persian]
  2. Abolghasemi, M. (1996). Dastoor-e Tarikhi-ye Zaban-e Farsi. first Edition. Tehran: Samt.
  3. Anvari, H. (2002). Farhang-e Bozorg-e Sokhan. 8 Vol. first Edition. Tehran: Sokhan.
  4. Anvari, H. & H. Ahmadi Givi. (1996). Dastoor-e Zaban-e Farsi 1. 10th Edition. Tehran: Fatemi.
  5. Anvari, H. & H. Ahmadi Givi. (1995). Dastoor-e Zaban-e Farsi 2. 6th Edition. Tehran: Fatemi.
  6. Beyhaghi, A. (1977). Tarikh-e Beyhaghi. Tashih-e ‘Ali Akbar Fayyaz. 2th Edition. Mashhad: Daneshgah-e Ferdowsi.
  7. Beyhaghi, A. (2022). Tarikh-e Beyhaghi, ba Tajdid-e Nazar va Afzoodeha va Eslahat–e Kamel. Tashih- Mohammad Ja'far Yahaghghi & Mehdi Seyyedi. 6th Edition. Tehran: Sokhan.
  8. Dehkhoda, ‘A A. (1993). Loghatname. first Edition of the new period. Tehran: Daneshgah-e Tehran.
  9. Gharib, ‘A. & Hamkaran. (1991). Dastoor Zaban-e Farsi (5 Ostad). be Kooshesh-e Amir Ashraf ol-Kottabi. 9th Edition. Tehran: Ashrafi.
  10. ‘Gholam’Alizadeh, KH. (2007). Sakht-e Zaban-e Farsi. 5th Edition. Tehran: Ehya’e Ketab.
  11. Mehravaran, M. (2009). Barrasi-ye ‘Ebarat-e Fe'li dar Dastoor Zaban-e Farsi. Fonoon-e Adabi. 1(1). Pp. 127-144. [In Persian]
  12. Natel Khanlari, P. (1987). Tarikh-e Zaban-e Farsi. Vol.2 & 3. 3th Edition. Tehran: Now.
  13. ‘Onsori, H. (1984). Divan-e ‘Onsori Balkhi. Tashih-e Mohammad Dabir Siyaghi. 2th Edition. Tehran: Ketabkhaneye
  14. Sana'i. Sana'i, M. (2006). Divan-e Hakim Abolmajd Majdood ebn Adam Sana'i. be Ehtemam-e Modarres Razavi. 6th Edition. Tehran: Sana'i.
Send comment about this article
CAPTCHA Image
Rhetoric and Grammar Studies
Volume 14, Issue 25
Spring and summer
August 2024
Pages 1-18

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics