Review and Criticism of Brevity Interruption in Persian Rhetorical Texts

Document Type : Rhetoric

Authors

1 Ph. D. Graduated of Persian Language and Literature, Faculty of Humanities, University of Zanjan, Zanjan, Iran

2 Associate Professor in the Department of Persian Language and Literature, Faculty of Humanities, University of Zanjan, Zanjan, Iran

10.22091/jls.2024.10371.1581

Abstract

Brevity is one of the important topics in the knowledge of meanings and is considered one of the pillars of rhetoric in speech, of course, sometimes there are reasons that disrupt this method and prevent it from its main function, which is to convey the message well and quickly. But the texts of Persian rhetoric have not paid attention to these causes of disturbances and have not regulated and compiled them. Therefore, it is necessary to examine and criticize the topic of disturbing brevity and carefully analyze these reasons in the definitions and examples of the mentioned topic. In the following article, an attempt has been made to review the definitions of disturbing brevity by analytical-critical re-reading of Persian rhetorical texts and to find the causes of disturbing brevity among these definitions and examples. The analysis of the data of this research shows that, although the texts of Persian rhetoric have expressed disturbing brevity and even sometimes examples containing this defect, but usually the definitions of disturbing brevity are vague, general and inconsistent with its examples, and there is no mentioning of the causes of disruption in brevity or if there is a reason, it is also inconsistent with the mentioned example. Another point is that the cause of the disturbance in speech is a linguistic rule, not a cultural one. Therefore, the main thing should be the language, not the audience. The causes of brevity in Persian rhetorical texts are the omission and non-observance of linguistic and grammatical rules. These two reasons are different according to the amount of disturbance they cause in the summary speech.

Keywords

Main Subjects

References

  1. Ahani, G.H. (1960). Naghd-e Ma’ani Dar San’at-e Nazm va Nasr-e Farsi. Esfahan: Tayid.
  2. ‘Alavi Moghaddam, M. & R. Ashrafzadeh. (2003). Ma’ani va Bayan. Tehran: Samt.
  3. Fotoohi, M. (2013). Nazokkhiyali-ye Esfahani va Doorkhiyali-ye Hendi. Name-ye Farhangestan. 1(1). Pp. 51-78. [In Persian]
  4. Ghahreman, M. (Nd.). Bargozide-ye ashʹar-e Sa’eb va Digar shoʹaraye Maʹroof-e Sabk-e Hendi. Tehran: Samt.
  5. Ghanipoor Malekshah, A. & Sattaari, R. & M. Moeddiniya. (2014). Shegerdha-ye Sanayi Dar Feshordegooyi va Ijaz. Adab va Zaban. 17(35). Pp. 291-316. [In Persian]
  6. Hesam al-ʹOlama, ʹA. (1937). Dorar ol-Adab. Qom: Hejrat.
  7. Homayi, J. (2010). Fonoon-e Balaghat va Sana’at-e Adabi. Tehran: Ahoora.
  8. Hoseini Soroori, N. & Kamkar Moqaddam, H. & ‘A. Jahan Sahi Afshar. (2016). Shegerdha-ye Khalgh-e Ijaz-e Honari Dar Golestan-e Sa’di. Balaghat-e Karbordi va Naghd-e Adabi. 2(1). Pp. 89-106. [In Persian]
  9. Kazzazi, M. (1994). Ma’ani. Tehran: Ketab-e Mad.
  10. Khakiyan, N. (2016). Barresi-ye Ghazaliyyat-e Bidel-e Dehlavi Az Manzar-e ʹElm-e Ma’ani (Ijaz va Etnab). Resale-ye Doctori. Be Rahnemayi-ye Narges Mohammadi Badr. Daneshgah-e Payam Noor-e Ostan-e Tehran.
  11. Mazandarani, M.H. (1997). Anvarol-Balaghe. Tashih-e Mohammad‘ali Gholami Nezhad. Tehran: Markaz-e Farhangi-ye Nashr-e Gheble va Daftar-e Nashr-e Miras-e Maktoob.
  12. Mehravaran, M. & M. Ghasemi. (2020). Ijazha-ye Ebhamparvar Dar Nasr-e Chahar ʹOnsor-e Bidel. Nasrpazhoohi-ye Adab-e Farsi. 23(48). Pp. 199-220. [In Persian]
  13. Mosaheb, Gh.H. (2002). Dayeratol-Maʹref-e Farsi. Vol. 1. Tehran: Amirkabir.
  14. Neshat, M. (1968). Zib-e Sokhan. Vol. 2. Tehran: Sherkat-e Sahami-ye chap va Entesharat-e Kotob-e Iran.
  15. Rajayi, M. (1974). Ma’alemol- Balaghe. Shiraz: Daneshgah-e Shiraz
  16. Rezanejad, G.H. (1988). Osool-e ʹElm-e Balaghat. Tehran: Alzahra.
  17. Rezayi, M. & A. Naghizadeh. (2015). Farahanjari Dar Sheʹr-e Sabk-e Hendi. Motaleʹat-e Zabani-Balaghi. 6(11). Pp. 69-94. [In Persian]
  18. Sa’eb Tabrizi. (1989). Divan-e Ghazaliyyat. vol 5. Tashih-e Mohammad Ghahraman. Tehran: ʹElmi va Frhangi.
  19. Safa, Z. (1958). Ayin-e Sokhan. Tehran: Np.
  20. Shamisa, S. (2007). Ma’ani. Tehran: Mitra.
  21. Shamisa, S. (2009). Sabkshenasi-ye Sheʹr. Tehran: Ferdows.
  22. Shams Gheys Razi. (2009). Almo’jam fi Ma’ayir-e ashʼar-e ol-ʼAjam. Tehran: ‘Elm.
  23. Tabatabayi, M.H. (Nd.). Nahayat ol-Hekma. Qom: Mo’assese-ye Nashr-e Eslami.
  24. Tabibiyan, H. (2019). Barabarha-ye ʹOloom-e Balaghat dar Farsi va ‘Arabi. Tehran: Amir Kabir.
  25. Taghavi, N. (1938). Hanjar-e Goftar. Tehram: Chapkhane-ye Majles.
  26. Va’ez Kashefi, H. (1990). Badayeol-Afkar. Tashih-e Mir jalaleddin Kazzazi. Tehran: nashr-e Makaz.
  27. Valeh Daghestani, ‘A. (2005). Riyazol-shoʹara. Vol. 1. Tashih-e Mohsen Naji Nasrabadi. Tehran: Asatir.
  28. Zahedi, Z. (Nd.). Ravesh-e Goftar. Mashhad: Daneshgah-e Mashhad.
Send comment about this article
CAPTCHA Image
Rhetoric and Grammar Studies
Volume 14, Issue 25
Spring and summer
August 2024
Pages 95-110

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics